KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

Mercari's Losers Only Need to Stop Losing to Lift the Stock

The U.S. unit and lending arm just need to prove they will not keep draining value.

AI image
doi.org · Mercari Deepdive Analysis

Linh Dan, author of a deep dive on Mercari, lists why investors still punish the company, the country's leading flea-market app, even as its core marketplace improved. The bear case has four familiar parts.

Investors believed the Japanese business, with about 23 million monthly users, had saturated. They distrusted the American expansion, feared credit risk in its payments and lending arm, and worried managers would reinvest any recovery instead of harvesting it.

That led to the distinction: “But there is a big difference between ‘uncertain’ and ‘value-destructive.’”

Uncertain describes the U.S. business, which never built anything like its Japanese position after strategic resets, unpopular fee changes, and fraud problems. It remains small, competitive, and hard to predict.

Value-destructive is the fear that the U.S. unit will keep consuming management time and shareholder money. If it can simply hover around breakeven or earn a small profit, investors can stop discounting the whole company for future damage.

He applies the same logic to the financial arm. “Mercari does not need investors to put a huge multiple on fintech.” It only needs to show that “it can be profitable and reasonably stable.” Then an old reason to avoid the stock fades.

Mercari does not need its American business to become a strategic winner, or its finance arm to become a separate franchise. It just needs both to stop scaring people long enough for the Japanese marketplace to be valued on its own.

Questions people ask

What exactly does Mercari do?

Mercari operates a smartphone app where individuals in Japan buy and sell used clothing, electronics, toys, and other goods. It handles payments, holds money in escrow until delivery, offers buyer protection, and arranges shipping to make strangers comfortable trading with each other.

Why would a small losing unit drag down a whole company?

Investors often value a company on its future cash flows, then subtract a penalty if they expect a side business to keep losing money or demand fresh investment. That penalty can depress the whole stock, even when the main business is healthy. Removing the expected loss can therefore raise the valuation without any new growth.

Is hovering near breakeven really enough?

It can, if the core business is strong enough to carry the valuation once the fear is gone. The risk is that breakeven proves temporary, especially in a competitive market or in lending if credit losses rise. That is why stable profitability matters.

More in Startups