Microsoft May Have Lived With Piracy to Hold Off Linux in China
A pirated copy of Windows still kept Chinese users inside Microsoft's world.

The Prof G Pod with Scott Galloway · China Decode: Microsoft's China Retreat, Remembering Zhu Rongji, and Typhoon Dolphin's AftermathIn the 1990s and 2000s, Microsoft software was widely copied without payment throughout China on what James King recalls as an extraordinary scale.
Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates said that more than 90 percent of personal computers in China ran Microsoft software. What he left unsaid was that almost all of it was pirated.
Microsoft is among the big Western firms that chased sales to more than a billion people but never fully won the China market. One reason was competition from free software.
That rival was Linux, a free, open source operating system whose basic code anyone can use, copy, and change. At the time, Chinese computer users were very keen on it.
The reasoning behind Microsoft's choice was straightforward. If Microsoft pushed harder to sell its products or cracked down on pirated copies, users might simply switch to Linux and Microsoft could lose the market altogether.
Gates summed up the tradeoff: "it's easier for our software to compete with Linux when there's piracy than when there's not." A pirated copy of Windows, in that logic, still kept the user on Windows.
Beijing backed Kylin, its own open source operating system. The move reflected concern about having too much technological exposure to a foreign supplier such as Microsoft.
Questions people ask
What exactly is Linux?
Linux is a free computer operating system, the basic software that manages files, programs, and hardware. Unlike Windows, its underlying code is open source, so anyone can view, modify, and share it. It now runs most web servers and supercomputers, along with Android phones.
What is Kylin, the Chinese system mentioned in the story?
Kylin is a computer operating system developed in China and based on Linux. It is intended for government offices, the military, and businesses as a homegrown alternative to Windows. Beijing has promoted it as a way to reduce dependence on American software.
Why didn't Microsoft simply force everyone to pay?
Enforcement would have been difficult, and the reasoning was that a crackdown risked driving users to Linux. Beijing was also concerned about too much technological exposure to a foreign supplier, as shown by its backing for Kylin.


