Pay CEOs for How Many Times Money Multiplies, Not How Fast
Investor Will Thorndike says avoiding annual return targets keeps managers and owners aligned, and rewards patience with a bigger stake.

Joys of Compounding · Will Thorndike - Lessons from the Eternal Outsider - [Joys of Compounding, EP.28]Investor Will Thorndike, who co-founded the investment firm Housatonic Partners, pays the young chief executives who run his long-hold companies for how many times money multiplies, not how fast.
He calls the financing behind those companies the equity paleo diet, meaning each one is built on what he calls "that base of equity and no more" and then held for a very long period. He calls that approach decadal, his word for incentives designed to keep an owner-operator in place for decades.
Those companies grow by buying and merging many small firms. In that kind of consolidation project, Thorndike argues, the usual model is to keep adding equity as long as the last dollars can still earn an acceptable yearly return.
That habit, he says, reflects the pull toward a larger next fund: "there's actually an incentive generally at the margin to deploy more equity because obviously that gets you closer to your next fund, raising your next fund."
The chief executive's pay works differently. Thorndike says their "economics are tied quite simply to net multiples of invested capital." A multiple, often shortened to MOIC, counts how many times cash multiplies, while IRR, or internal rate of return, measures speed per year.
The reason, based on his experience with such tests, is mathematical and can create misalignment even with the best teams. "It gets hard to maintain a 35% IRR or whatever the threshold is," Thorndike says, so yearly-rate targets can pit managers against investors. A payout tied to the multiple, he argues, stays aligned on its own.
Investors still control the board and any sale. But if returns fade, Thorndike believes the chief executives themselves will tend to favor selling if they doubt the business can keep growing.
The payout runs on what he calls a system of doubles, at two times, four times, and so on. In a typical startup, he says, a founder begins with the largest stake he will ever hold and is then diluted lower with each fundraising.
Here a founder who keeps pushing the multiple higher can instead own a larger percentage over time. Thorndike says, "The team running things actually gets more and more skin in the game as the multiple and capital outcomes appreciate," giving both managers and investors reason to keep holding, but only, in his words, "if in fact, the story is still intact."
The long wait does the filtering. Ownership takes roughly three to seven years to become meaningful, with the larger reward possible in the decade after that, around year 10. Few managers or backers will accept that delay, so the design screens for people willing to stay.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between MOIC and IRR?
MOIC tells you how many times money multiplied, so money that turns $10 million into $40 million is 4x whenever it happens. IRR turns that result into a yearly speed, so the same 4x earns a much higher IRR in four years than in 14 years. Thorndike prefers MOIC because a high yearly rate gets mathematically harder to sustain over a long hold.
How can a CEO's ownership percentage go up over time?
Thorndike ties the payout to what he calls a system of doubles, at two times, four times, and so on. As the multiple and capital outcomes appreciate, he says founders can increase their percentage ownership. He describes that as a reflexive and reinforcing form of alignment.
Why use so little equity to start?
Thorndike says the aim is to start lean and stay lean, then own the business for very long periods. He is backing an early career operator to run it for decades, rather than deploying as much equity as possible.


