Pick Work You Like Where No Star Owns the Niche
Appellate lawyer Jaime Santos skipped the star path and claimed defense-side retirement plan appeals, then spent years speaking and volunteering to expand her network.

Original Jurisdiction · ‘There’s Always A Way’: Jaime SantosAppellate lawyer Jaime Santos did not have the usual star resume, no Supreme Court clerkship and no turn in the Solicitor General's office. She built a practice anyway by picking an open niche and working to raise her profile and expand her network.
Her method has two parts. First, choose work you genuinely like, then check whether anyone already owns it. Santos wanted to stay a generalist who argues appeals, but she knew she needed one or two specialties she could market and speak about.
Sitting in her Washington office, she ran down the list. She liked patent, antitrust, and bankruptcy appeals, but each field already had a go-to advocate with deeper credentials. She recalled thinking that no client would hire her over those established names.
She had handled some cases under ERISA, the federal law that governs retirement and health plans. Santos said she liked the mix of administrative law, statutory interpretation, and some common law, adding, "It also is very complicated and everyone else hates it."
Crucially, no one dominated defense-side ERISA appeals. On the plaintiffs' side there were well known appellate lawyers, while representing employers left the field open with no clear leader.
Second, get very good and get visible at the same time. Santos spent more than five years honing her appellate craft while treating profile building as a side job. She has said that being smart and hardworking is not enough to get hired in Washington.
Her visibility work was deliberately broad. She spoke at law schools and conferences on appellate practice, diversity, and working motherhood. She worked with current and former clerks on federal court misconduct procedures, advised courts around the country, testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee and the Judicial Conference, helped start a podcast, and served as secretary of a Washington appellate group that meets monthly during the Supreme Court term.
Questions people ask
What is ERISA?
ERISA is a 1974 federal law that sets rules for most private employer retirement plans and health plans. It controls how plans are funded, managed, and challenged in court.
How do I tell if a niche is actually open?
List the matters you enjoy, then search who argues, writes, and speaks on them most often. Look for repeat names at conferences, in major briefs, and in news coverage. An opening is a field you like where the same two or three names do not appear every time.
What is a manageable first step to become more visible?
Start with one talk, article, or bar committee role tied to your chosen niche. Santos said yes to almost anything at first, from law schools to misconduct reform, because each appearance expanded her network. Keep the topic close enough to your day job that preparation makes you better at the work itself.

