Porn Defenders Ignore The Power Of Algorithms
Writers Josephine Bartosch and Robert Jessel argue free speech defenses miss how platforms steer what viewers want next.

thecritic.co.uk · When freedom isn’t free | Josephine Bartosch and Robert Jessel | The Critic MagazineWriters Josephine Bartosch and Robert Jessel weighed in on proposed amendments to Britain's Crime and Policing Bill, still pending, that would limit explicit material involving strangulation, incest and simulated abuse of children. The loudest objections, they note, warned of censorship and intrusion into private life.
Their target is what they see as a narrow view of power. In their account, many defenders act as if the state is the only force that can curb private choice, while overlooking commercial systems that steer attention and appetite.
That blind spot, write Bartosch and Jessel, includes "the algorithms that shape what millions watch, think, feel and desire." For sophisticated supporters, they add, appeals to free expression have become the beginning and end of the argument.
They concede why those supporters feel confident that courts will block such bans. That confidence rests on history: a 1980s American city law that treated pornography as sex discrimination was struck down under the First Amendment, and later restrictions generally met the same fate in America.
So defenders focused only on preserving access, the writers say, have precedent on their side. The pending amendments would test that protection again, but past rulings give free speech claims real weight.
Their argument is that winning the legal point does not answer the commercial point. The sites, they argue, are engineered to extend viewing sessions, while the material itself can reshape what viewers want.
That is why they urge skeptics of power to look beyond government. In their view, scrutiny should fall on the companies and designers who choose the next video, keep viewers engaged, and profit from their wants.
No past ruler, in the writers' telling, has matched that intimate reach into what people feel and want. Claiming to defend liberty, they conclude, can feel more flattering than examining how recommendation software steers appetite.
Questions people ask
What restrictions were being debated?
The proposal discussed in the article would further restrict extreme pornography, including depictions of incest, strangulation and simulated child abuse. The authors describe it as amendments to a crime bill, and as an effort to align what can be shown online with what licensed sex shops can already sell.
What was the Dworkin-MacKinnon Ordinance?
It was a 1980s anti pornography ordinance, drafted by feminist scholars Andrea Dworkin and Catharine MacKinnon and passed in Indianapolis. It defined pornography as sex discrimination and let people harmed by it seek damages, but courts struck it down as a violation of the First Amendment.
Do porn sites really use recommendation algorithms?
Yes. The largest adult video sites operate like other video platforms, with homepages, autoplay, recommended videos and personalized rankings. Those systems are built to increase viewing time, which in turn increases advertising and subscription revenue.


