Put Your Toughest Critic in Charge of the Work
A former SEAL platoon leader found even elite troops disengage without ownership, until the critic becomes the planner.
Not Dead Yet · Leif BabinLeif Babin, a former Navy SEAL officer who led a platoon in Iraq, learned that danger alone does not keep people engaged. Even in his decorated unit, two men volunteered to stay an additional six months while others grew tired, burned out, and ready to go home.
The difference, he concluded, was ownership. They did everything he asked, he says, but the men who turned negative thought leaders were inventing reckless operations that might get them killed.
What those skeptics did not know was that, as Babin put it, "we turned down probably a dozen operations" as too dangerous, unlikely to succeed, or not worth the risk. The grumblers were busy prepping charges, maintaining vehicles, and sighting weapons, then walking into briefs with no view of those calls.
His remedy sounds backward: put the complainer in charge. Babin said, "now it's very hard to complain about a plan if it's your plan."
In his training example, Babin says he tells the unhappy teammate he understands the objection and has listened to the complaint. Then he asks the teammate to lead the upcoming training sessions.
The teammate is to come talk through what topics he wants to cover and how he wants to do it. The turnaround can be striking, Babin says, though not every time, and with ownership people begin to see why the work is done and how it ties to larger goals.
Questions people ask
Doesn't this reward complaining?
No, if you frame it as responsibility rather than reward. You are not endorsing the eye rolls, you are asking the person to solve the problem he identified, with clear standards and a deadline.
How much control should I keep?
Give bounded freedom. Let the person choose the topic, format, and schedule, but require advance approval and a clear link to the team's goal. Keep the assignment small and real so a mistake is instructive, not costly.
What if he still complains after running it?
Then you have useful information. If he tried and still struggles, coach him on planning and priorities. If he will not try, you can address performance directly because you removed the excuse of having no voice.


