KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

Rival Voters Applauded Each Other, Then Sang Together and Sometimes Cried

Iowa governor-elect Rob Sand used the ritual in every county twice to show that disagreement can come before unity.

AI image
The Ezra Klein Show · The Winning Democrat Who Wants to Break Up Political Parties

It started with a show of hands. Rob Sand, the Democrat who ran for governor of Iowa, asked the Republicans in the room to identify themselves.

Then he asked everyone else to applaud them. He repeated it for independents, and then for Democrats, asking people to literally applaud neighbors they disagreed with.

Then he led the whole room in singing America the Beautiful together. He did it at 200 public town halls, in every Iowa county twice, and people sometimes cried.

Sand said the tears came because the ritual did not ask people to pretend they agreed. It began by naming their differences, and then asked them to unite anyway.

Someone in the crowd usually had to start the song, he said. Once one strong voice picked it up, the rest joined in on spacious skies and amber waves of grain.

Ezra Klein, the interviewer, noted research finding that nothing makes people feel more connected than singing or dancing together. Sand said he had not known that when he started, and that halfway through the campaign a friend named Katie told him that singing together can sync brain waves.

Even 200 times in, Sand said, he still sometimes had to stop singing because he got emotional. Sand said he still feels it when he thinks about it: "this idea that we are going to do this together, even though we disagree."

Questions people ask

Does singing together really make people feel closer?

Yes. Studies of group singing and synchronized movement find higher trust, cooperation, and feelings of closeness afterward, even among strangers. Researchers think the effect comes from breathing together, paying joint attention, and making the same sound at the same time.

Who is Rob Sand, and did the town halls help him win?

Sand was Iowa's state auditor before running for governor as a Democrat. He won by about 11 points, running well ahead of recent Democratic candidates in the state, and drew support that included more than 3,000 Republican donors.

Will he keep holding town halls now that he is governor?

He has promised to hold 100 public town halls a year as governor. He says the sessions build trust because he tells voters when a request is unrealistic or legally impossible, rather than making promises he cannot keep.

More in Psychology