She Was Not Hot Enough for the Lead, and Not Odd Enough
She saved every failed audition script and reread them on bad weekends, until a friend stepped in.

Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard · Rhea SeehornThe casting director walked Rhea Seehorn out of the audition herself, with a tone that sounded as if she was being an ally.
“You're obviously the best person for the job,” the woman said. “But you and I both know they're going to have to get somebody hot.”
For years, that was the trap Seehorn described. She said she was told to her face, “not hot enough to actually be the romantic lead, but not ugly enough to be the character partner.”
At the time, she was blonde and blue eyed and had lost weight, so she was sent to try out for parts as the girlfriend. Those are the parts where the woman stands beside the male lead, and Seehorn said she was not really supposed to make them interesting.
Trying to make those roles three dimensional, which she saw as her job, became a problem in itself. She also said she was not character looking enough to get the other kind of work, the quirky side parts that turn on an unusual face or manner.
That stretch, she said, was very real and very hard. After rejections, she saved the sides, the few pages of script actors use to prepare a tryout, from every part she did not get.
On weekends when she felt down on herself, she would spread out those pages and go back through them to figure out what she had done wrong.
A friend finally stepped in and told her, “You have to stop this or I'm going to stop it for you.”
Seehorn said the ally-like tone of the walk to the door made it worse. She did not know whether to nod along or to argue that she was hot, so she just shut up.
Questions people ask
What are audition sides?
Sides are a few pages of a script that an actor is given to prepare for a tryout. They usually contain the character's key scenes, and actors often get them only a day or two before the audition.
Did Seehorn eventually break out of that in-between category?
Yes. After years of theater and small television parts, she was cast as lawyer Kim Wexler on Better Call Saul, a performance that earned her two Emmy nominations. She now leads the drama Pluribus as Carol Sturka.
Is looks-based typecasting still common in Hollywood?
It is still common, though the categories have widened. Casting directors often start with appearance and age as shorthand for a role, especially for romantic leads. Successes by actors who do not fit the old molds have created more exceptions, but not erased the shorthand.


