KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

The Best Startup Ideas Look Like Terrible Ideas at First

That early skepticism keeps competitors away and leaves room to dominate a small market first.

AI image
YC Root Access · Lecture 1 - How to Start a Startup (Sam Altman, Dustin Moskovitz)

In 2014, Sam Altman, then president of the startup funder Y Combinator, told Stanford students that picking an idea meant accepting an uncomfortable truth. Winners did not look like winners at the start.

"You want to sound crazy but you want to actually be right," he said.

By crazy, he meant pitches that made sensible people shrug. The 13th search engine, stripped of portal extras, looked pointless when portals seemed to hold the value.

The 10th social network, aimed only at students with little spending power, looked just as bad after MySpace had won. A service for sleeping on the couches of strangers sounded terrible all around.

Altman said that cold reaction was useful. If an idea had sounded obviously good, too many people would have been working on it, so, as Altman put it, "in many ways it's easier to start a hard startup than an easy startup."

Startups that merely imitated what already existed did not excite people or push teams to work hard enough, he said. He wanted an idea that could become a monopoly by taking a small market first and then expanding fast.

It helped, he said, if a founder could say that only a small group would use the product at first, but he would win all of them and later almost everyone would use it. A first version did not need to sound big, it had to dominate a narrow and specific market.

That took conviction and a willingness to ignore naysaying, since most people would think a great idea was bad. He said founders should welcome that reaction, because it meant rivals would not compete and the idea would not sound worth stealing.

The test was whether a founder could say, "I know it sounds like a bad idea but here is specifically why it is actually a great one." What Altman said he was looking for was unpopular but right.

Questions people ask

How do you tell the difference between crazy-wrong and crazy-right?

Altman gave no formula. His test was whether you could state specifically why the bad sounding idea was actually good. That took conviction in your own beliefs and a clear view of how the market would grow.

Why start with a small market instead of going big right away?

A small market let a startup win all of its first users and expand from there, since Altman said in 2014 that you could not win a monopoly in a big market right away. It also helped to show that only a small group used the product then but almost everyone might later. Altman said Peter Thiel, the investor and PayPal co-founder, would discuss monopolies in the fifth class.

What did Altman mean by saying a hard startup is easier than an easy one?

He meant obvious, easy ideas drew too much competition. Startups that merely imitated what already existed did not excite people or make teams work hard enough. A hard idea could inspire the conviction and focus a team needed to keep going.

More in Startups