KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

The Harder It Is to Join, the More You Value Belonging

An embarrassing tryout made a boring lecture seem interesting, and the same logic keeps people loyal to tough pastimes.

AI image
My First Million · She’s making $40M selling a game to rich moms

There is a strange reason the hardest clubs inspire the fiercest loyalty: the pain of getting in makes belonging feel more valuable.

The idea is called the severity of initiation. Businessman Shaan Puri puts it this way: "The harder it is to get into a club, the more everybody's going to value being in the club."

In a psychology experiment, women applied to join a club about sexual wellness. To get in, one group had to read a highly embarrassing passage in front of men, a second group read something milder, and a third read nothing at all.

Then all of them heard the same lecture on the topic, which was boring on purpose. The women who paid no price called it boring and did not want to return. Those with mild embarrassment were lukewarm, while those who had suffered the most embarrassment convinced themselves it was interesting.

The logic runs backward. As Puri describes it, the brain reasons, "if I did so much to get in, this can't be bad." He compares it to a Michelin star restaurant, where after dressing up, waiting, and paying a lot, a spoonful of food can still earn raves.

In that version, the cost was embarrassment, not time or effort. Later versions of the experiment used electric shocks as the price of admission, and the result held.

That helps explain pastimes with steep entry costs. CrossFit demands intense physical effort and injury risk, while wine keeps high barriers to entry. Once inside, members know the lingo, follow the patterns, own the gear, and wear membership as a badge of honor.

Puri calls it costly signaling. Membership advertises identity and tribe, but entry was very costly, and he puts golf and sushi in the same group.

Mahjong, he argues, rides on that effect, plus the appeal of a tactile, no phone social activity. "People are kind of like lonely and want to get offline," he says.

Questions people ask

Should every business make it harder to join?

No. Puri describes it as a tradeoff: you will lose some people because there is too much friction up front. But he says the people who do get in have high lifetime value and spread strong word of mouth.

How does a painful entry support higher prices?

Puri's example is wine, which he says keeps high barriers to entry so it can charge what it charges. Once inside, people get to feel special because they know what makes it special.

More in Psychology