Three Grammys Barely Registered Because Success Became the Minimum Bar
Dan + Shay and a fellow creator describe how a chart high or an award quickly turns from celebration into expectation.

Modern Wisdom · “We Won 3 Grammys and Still Felt Like Failures” - Dan + Shay (Live Performance) - #1176Country singers Dan Smyers and Shay Mooney, who record as Dan + Shay, were trading stories about the pressure of following hits like Tequila with creator Chris Williamson when Williamson offered his own chart story as the lesson.
“If I’m good at things that makes success no longer a cause for celebration, but the minimum bar of acceptable performance,” he said.
Last year his show reached No. 8 in the world on Spotify, built from a bedroom setup in northeast England, and the glow lasted about half an hour before he caught himself fearing what would happen if he did not reach No. 7 next year.
He argues that success does not fill the inner void people expect, so motivation has to be rebuilt around craft and purpose, staying driven enough to keep improving without becoming so competitive that gratitude disappears.
Mooney said he recognized the pattern. At the 2018 Country Music Association Awards, the duo was up for eight or nine trophies, figured the odds favored at least one win, and lost every one, an experience he said taught them how risky it is to tie self-worth to awards.
The opposite then happened. They won three Grammys but were so busy chasing the next milestone that they barely stopped to absorb it, though Mooney said his 10-year-old self would have called that career unbelievable.
Mooney says his job in the partnership is blind optimism, and says “we have made each other better,” adding that he believes he has made Smyers a happier person.
Smyers, who describes himself as a pessimistic workaholic from Pittsburgh, said he could win a Grammy and still think, because someone else also won that night, that they had failed, a mindset that leaves him feeling guilty for probably cheating himself out of good years and moments.
Questions people ask
Have Dan + Shay really won three Grammys?
They have three. Two were for best country duo or group performance, for Tequila and Speechless, and one was for best country song, for Tequila. All came in 2019 and 2020, during their mainstream breakthrough.
Why does a big win stop feeling good so fast?
Psychologists often call it the hedonic treadmill. People adapt to a higher income, bigger house, award, or ranking, then return near their earlier level of satisfaction. The new level soon feels normal, so the next gain promises happiness again without delivering it for long.
How do they try to break the cycle?
Williamson says he tries to judge an episode by his excitement before making it and his satisfaction afterward, not by chart position or comments. Mooney and Smyers describe a similar reset, focusing on craft, gratitude, and seeing careers in seasons. The aim is to stay competitive without living only in what is still missing.



