KorvaJoin the waitlist
Art

Trust the Idea You Cannot Defend

Producer Rick Rubin says reason is a tiny sliver of decision making, and the best work cannot be defended.

AI image
The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett · Rick Rubin: What Jay-Z Did in 30 Minutes Left Me Speechless!

Steven Bartlett, the entrepreneur and podcast host, asked Rick Rubin, the veteran record producer, for a principle that works for any kind of problem. Rubin offered an odd one.

"Indefensible is actually a good thing," Rubin said. He meant that the strongest choices go beyond reason, and reason is, in Rubin's words, "a tiny sliver of how decisions get made."

For Rubin, the better guide is intuition, or what Rubin describes as guidance from "the creative force of the universe," which he calls God. It is a feeling that a thing is right even when you cannot explain why.

That feeling is his test for art. Rubin says that if an artist makes something and thinks everyone will love it, it is too easy. The best work, Rubin says, is the thing the maker feels is deeply meaningful but suspects no one will like, and cannot defend.

He says he has often not liked new art on first contact because it was too much. For true revolutionary works, he says, we don't yet have context for them.

He points to Yeezus, the album by rapper Kanye West that he helped make. It was built intentionally as "a sort of an anti-hip hop album," Rubin said, pushed as far as they could into what Rubin calls the indefensible realm. Bartlett, a Kanye fan, said he was confused when he first heard it, then after a while came to love it.

Rubin asked Bartlett if it was an important album to him now, Bartlett said yes, and Rubin answered, "Okay. Did its job."

Rubin says that in his work with artists, they never consider near term incentives, not once. He describes everything made as a diary entry, a personal true expression of how the maker sees the world, and Rubin asks, "Can someone else read your diary entry and tell you it's wrong?"

Questions people ask

Does Rubin mean artists should ignore whether anyone likes their work?

He says the work should be truly personal, and if someone does not get it, they just do not get it yet, or maybe never will, and that is fine. The aim he describes is honesty about how he sees the world, which can show listeners something they had not considered.

Why do strange new albums often sound bad at first?

Psychologists call it the mere exposure effect, and listeners tend to prefer sounds their brains already know how to process. A record with unfamiliar rhythms, tones, or structures can feel unpleasant until repeated listens build a mental template. That learning curve is why some records grow on people over weeks or years.

More in Art