KorvaJoin the waitlist
Tech

Winning Elections Is a Different Skill Than Governing

Ezra Klein says vote margins reveal little about who will matter in Congress.

AI image
The Ezra Klein Show · The End of Trumpism

Ezra Klein, a political commentator, was weighing Democratic contests that were still being counted, debating what progressive candidates had proved, when he paused the scorekeeping.

Klein argued that winning votes and governing well take different talents. Klein called Elizabeth Warren, a Democratic senator from Massachusetts, "one of the most important senators" because she stands out as a creative policy thinker, even though she "is not an incredible electoral performer by any means."

In his view, many of the most creative and important members of Congress hold secure seats without facing constant risk of defeat. That security, he suggested, leaves more room for policy work.

To illustrate another kind of promise, Klein pointed to Abdul El-Sayed, a Michigan Democratic candidate for the Senate. He said El-Sayed had succeeded in academics, medicine and sports, and that they had focused on that life story when speaking with him.

Klein said the effort targeting El-Sayed was grotesque, and "what they tried to do to El-Sayed" was reprehensible. He said, "I find El-Sayed to be a very impressive person."

He said how such newcomers perform in the Senate or House is a separate matter from whether their races offer lessons about competing where the party has not competed before.

Klein noted El-Sayed was projected to win by seven or eight points, or whatever the final count would be, while votes were still being tallied. In Klein's comparison, that projected margin looked less impressive at a time when the national mood favored Democrats by about 13 points. Klein argued that kind of result taught little about future races in places where the party has not competed.

Questions people ask

Who is Elizabeth Warren?

She is a Democratic senator from Massachusetts and a former Harvard law professor. She is known for plans to regulate banks, cancel student debt, and expand consumer protections, and she ran for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2020.

Who is Abdul El-Sayed?

He is a Michigan physician, author, and Democratic political candidate. He trained in medicine and public health, earned a Rhodes Scholarship to study at Oxford, and later served as Detroit's health director.

Why might holding a safe seat make a lawmaker more creative?

Lawmakers who do not fear losing every two or six years can take risks on new bills and spend time on detailed policy. Vulnerable members often spend more time fundraising, campaigning, and avoiding controversial votes.

More in Tech