KorvaJoin the waitlist
Health

A Garlic Maker Argues That a Bigger Milligram Number Is Not More

LaValle claims a larger milligram figure can describe a different product, not more of the tested extract.

AI image
HEALTH TALK AMERICA · The Copycat Aisle: A Blood Pressure Bombshell, the 7,500-Milligram Question, and the Garlic That Got photocopied

This account comes from a promotional hour of Health Talk America in which host Adam Brockman repeatedly urged listeners to buy Kyolic aged garlic extract. His guest was Jim LaValle, a clinical pharmacist and board-certified clinical nutritionist, who argued that a larger milligram number can mean a different product rather than more of the same one.

LaValle contrasted soft gels labeled 7,500 milligrams with doses of 600 to 1,200 milligrams of the product he discusses. He claimed the larger figure did not provide additional amounts of the formula used in the trials he cites.

Formulation is the recipe for a pill and the active ingredient is the part of that recipe thought to do the work.

The product LaValle discusses is Kyolic aged garlic extract, which he describes as garlic aged in vats for about 20 months. That aging, he says, transforms sharp smelling compounds that dissolve in oil into compounds that dissolve in water.

He stresses that aging is a different process from fermentation. He says aging creates those water-soluble compounds. He describes fermentation as using a specific medium, as when cabbage becomes sauerkraut, while aging simply holds the garlic over time to develop its compounds.

LaValle says quality is checked during that long aging and then in studies in people. He presents testing through production and human trials as the reason to trust one recipe over another.

For that aged garlic extract, LaValle says most studies used roughly one to two grams per day. He described a gingivitis study that used about three and one-half grams per day and, in his account, reported smaller dental pockets and less gum inflammation.

LaValle calls the 7,500-milligram figure a marketing number rather than a medical number. He claims it has no corresponding trials behind it and was never studied as a dose.

Questions people ask

Why does LaValle object to soft gels for aged garlic?

LaValle points to S-allylcysteine, a marker he says is water soluble and better suited to liquid, powder, capsules, or tablets. He says oil based soft gels are built for ingredients that dissolve in oil, such as fish oil or CoQ10, and that garlic oil has a different compound profile.

How much research does LaValle claim sits behind the product?

LaValle describes more than 200 clinical studies and more than 1,000 published papers. Those totals are his characterization of the research base, not an independent count, and he presents them as unusually large for a supplement.

More in Health