KorvaJoin the waitlist
Books

A Murder Conviction Without Saying He Did It

Accused killer James Smith used the deal to avoid a possible death sentence, and Laura McNaughton's mother later wished she had insisted on a trial.

AI image
Dateline NBC · Hunted

On December 12, 2006, James Smith stood in a Clovis courtroom and accepted a murder conviction without saying he committed murder.

That is how an Alford plea works. The defendant agrees that prosecutors have enough evidence to convict him, and the judge sentences him as guilty, but he does not admit that he did it.

In this case, Smith acknowledged the state could convict him of murder, kidnapping, and attempted sexual assault in the killing of Laura McNaughton. He never told the court that he killed her.

Prosecutor Matt Chandler said Smith was eligible for the death penalty, which New Mexico still allowed at the time. Smith faced a murder charge along with kidnapping and attempted sexual assault.

Defense lawyer Mark Ernest said the death penalty changes everything. It would have required a second strategy to persuade a jury to spare Smith if he were found guilty, including a psychological examination to explore why the crime happened.

According to Ernest, Smith did not want to undergo that examination. With a wife and two small children, his lawyer said, he did not want his family pushed into a high profile trial with unusual facts aired in open court.

Chandler said Laura's family also dreaded hearing the evidence. So both sides negotiated an agreement that avoided trial entirely.

At the hearing, Laura's mother, Lucky Beardmore, told Smith he could have gone to a priest, minister, or counselor before the killing. Her husband, David Beardmore, said Smith avoided looking at the family.

The sentence was life plus 27 years, which means Smith would be over 90 before he could even be considered for release. Laura's parents call the prison every year to make sure he is still there.

The tradeoff still stings. Lucky later wished they had demanded a trial instead, because Smith never acknowledged his actions in court.

Questions people ask

Where does the name Alford plea come from?

It comes from a 1970 U.S. Supreme Court case, North Carolina v. Alford. Henry Alford pleaded guilty to avoid the death penalty while insisting he was innocent, and the Court ruled that a judge may accept the plea when strong evidence of guilt exists.

Is an Alford plea the same as pleading no contest?

They are similar but not identical. With no contest, also called nolo contendere, the defendant does not admit or deny the charge and generally cannot have the plea used against him in a civil lawsuit. An Alford plea more directly acknowledges that prosecutors could prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Is the death penalty still available in New Mexico?

New Mexico abolished the death penalty for new crimes in 2009, and the state Supreme Court later ruled that remaining death sentences could not be carried out. At the time of Smith's case in 2006, however, execution was still a lawful punishment prosecutors could seek.

More in Books