The Prosecutor's Son Who Decided Chester Weger Was Innocent
Raised to fear Chester Weger, David Recuglia met him in prison and came to think he was innocent.

Stuff You Should Know · The Story of Chester WegerDecades after Chester Weger went to prison for the 1960 murders of three women at Starved Rock State Park in Illinois, an unexpected supporter joined the effort to free him.
He was David Recuglia, the son of Anthony Recuglia, the assistant prosecutor who had helped convict Weger of murdering Lillian Oding, one of the three victims.
David had grown up thinking of Weger as the boogeyman, because of his father's role in the case. As an adult, he met with Weger and came to think he was innocent.
The case against Weger centered on a confession. Weger, then a 21-year-old dishwasher at the park lodge, confessed after about eight hours of overnight questioning, then recanted the next day.
He said deputies had threatened him and fed him details, including a red-and-white airplane he said he had seen over the canyon. Prosecutors charged him only in Oding's killing, preserving the option to try him later in the other two deaths.
At trial, prosecutors had almost no physical proof linking Weger to the killings, so his admission carried the case. Weger testified for three hours that he had been coerced, but the jury convicted him after about 10 hours of deliberation.
In 2010, Anthony Recuglia said Weger's account of the killings had made little sense and was not very believable, but that the admission itself had been enough.
David met with Weger in prison and began shooting video about the case. Much of that footage was later used in a 2021 documentary about the murders.
Weger never admitted guilt, and after 24 parole requests he was released in 2020 at age 80. Analysts working for his defense later reported, using genealogical databases, that hairs from the crime scene were not Weger's and pointed to a family with several brothers living near the park; the family was not named, and a judge ruled the DNA was not enough to throw out the verdict.
Weger died of cancer in 2025 at age 86, after 58 years in prison, still formally convicted of the murder.
Questions people ask
Who were the victims in the Starved Rock case?
The three women were friends who had checked into the lodge for a vacation. Lillian Oding, Mildred Lindquist, and Frances Murphy left for a late-afternoon birdwatching hike in St. Louis Canyon in March 1960 and were found beaten to death in a cave.
Why did Weger say he confessed if he was innocent?
He said interrogators questioned him through the night, threatened him with the death penalty, and promised a lighter sentence if he confessed. He also said details in his statement, including the airplane, were supplied to him by deputies.
What did the later DNA testing show?
Testing in recent years focused on hairs found in a victim's glove and blood on Weger's jacket. Analysts said the hairs pointed to a family with several brothers living near the park at the time, and that they were not Weger's.

