KorvaJoin the waitlist
Books

AI Book Clones Are Not Unstoppable

She argues that separate, people-run systems can keep human writing easy to find and harder to copy.

AI image
TechCrunch · Flaming Hydra’s new Kickstarter campaign rethinks e-book ownership and digital lending | TechCrunch

When Maria Bustillos, lead editor of the online culture magazine Flaming Hydra, explained her new publishing project, she kept returning to a fellow writer's trouble. Tal Levin had written for Flaming Hydra after spotting many AI-made copies of his book listed for sale on Amazon.

For Bustillos, the episode showed what happens to writers when their work moves through large, automated marketplaces. Her response was not to treat the copying as inevitable.

"AI is not this unstoppable force," she said.

She argued that writers can protect themselves by building a different kind of system. By creating an ecosystem based on people working together, and offering work in a controlled context that does not allow cloning, Bustillos said Flaming Hydra is "part of the human project."

In her view, that means setting up publishing pipelines, networks, and organizations dedicated to what she calls the human internet. Readers who want human-made work could go directly to those networks, which she described as isolated from automated interference.

Her current effort, called the Phoenix Project, fits that outlook by helping libraries offer readers more work from real writers. The idea is to give readers a reliable place to find that work, rather than leaving distribution to systems that only license books and can later alter or withdraw them.

She tied the same concern to schools and libraries. She pointed to a case she wrote about in 2020 in which a school faced a yearly fee of $27 for each student to keep using The Diary of Anne Frank, instead of simply buying the book.

In her telling, if people build and keep up those networks, wider access to human-made work can go together with protecting the right of writers to make a living.

Questions people ask

What is the Phoenix Project actually building?

It combines three efforts: a one-off print magazine celebrating the values and fun of the early internet, a service for lending e-books through libraries, and a program to archive newsletters and make them available for lending. The common goal is wider access to human-made work while still letting writers earn a living.

Why don't libraries already own the e-books they lend?

Most trade publishers license e-books to libraries rather than selling them outright. Those licenses often limit how many times a book can be lent, how long access lasts, or what it costs to renew. That is why access can expire or require repeated payments.

How do AI-generated clones of real books end up for sale?

Third parties can use AI tools to quickly rewrite, summarize, or imitate a real book, then publish the result under a similar title or author name. Online bookstores process very large numbers of new titles, so lookalike books can appear before they are caught. Authors usually must find the copies and file complaints to have them removed.

More in Books