KorvaJoin the waitlist
Books

Ron Charles Worries Most About Debut Books As Reviews Fade

The former Post critic says fewer professional reviews leave little-known and boundary-pushing titles without champions.

AI image
Marketplace · IPOs grow and grow

In February, Ron Charles, the longtime book critic at the Washington Post, lost his job when the paper ended its book review section. Within hours, after a friend who had been an agent told him to use his 15 minutes of fame, he announced he would continue his criticism on Substack.

Charles, who now has more than 37,000 subscribers on Substack, says his concern is not the best known authors. As Charles puts it, "As that fades away, that whole ecosystem becomes more of a monoculture thing."

By ecosystem, he means publishing needs both its big trees, the big name authors and books with large publicity budgets, and its smaller growth. He worries most about first-time writers and books on narrow or unusual subjects, work that needs many critics to find it and bring it to attention.

That worry is shared by Adam Levy, who with his wife runs Transit Books, a nonprofit publisher based in Berkeley with five full-time employees. Transit published May We Feed the King, which was shortlisted for the Booker Prize, and Levy says boundary-pushing books can get left behind with fewer review sections.

As Levy puts it, "They need to be argued over, thought through." He adds, "It takes people who are looking around with a really careful eye to help make that stuff possible."

Questions people ask

How widespread are the cuts to book reviews?

The Associated Press has not published a book review in more than a year, and book coverage has been thinned at many other newspapers. Papers have cut specialist sections as print advertising declined and newsrooms shrank, and reviews were often among the first features to go.

Where are readers finding book recommendations now?

Charles now makes a living on Substack, where enough readers pay for his reviews and he can experiment and talk directly with readers. Readers also find books through prizes, TikTok reviewers, and booksellers. Charles says he worries that with fewer review outlets, readers have fewer ways to find the book that is right for them.

What does it mean that Transit Books is a nonprofit publisher?

It is a publisher that does not aim to earn profits for owners and often relies on donations and grants as well as sales. Transit Books is based in Berkeley and has five full-time employees.

More in Books