A Pilot Found No Trace Of A Deadly System In His Manual
When pilots demanded answers in Texas, a Boeing vice president dismissed the idea that an undisclosed system mattered.

American Scandal · Encore: Boeing | Impact | 1On Nov. 11, 2018, about two weeks after Lion Air Flight 610 fell into the Java Sea, American Airlines pilot Dennis Taser opened an email from Boeing.
Taser was a longtime American pilot serving as a spokesman for its pilots union, the Allied Pilots Association. He was scanning for an explanation of the crash.
About halfway down, he stopped cold. The message said the Lion Air plane had suffered an erroneous activation of MCAS.
Taser had never heard of MCAS and could not guess what the initials meant. He swiveled in his chair and grabbed his flight manual for the Boeing 737 MAX 8, a thick book of more than 1,000 pages.
He checked the table of contents, found nothing, then tried the index. It listed one page for MCAS, a glossary of abbreviations that said only that the letters stood for Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System.
That was the whole entry behind a system now linked to a crash that killed all 189 people aboard, while American and other airlines were still flying the same model. Taser was furious that pilots had been left to fly a plane with a powerful system they had never been told about.
Reporters soon learned what that system could do. If it sensed the plane climbing too steeply, it automatically pushed the nose down, and pilots could not stop it by hauling back on the wheel in the cockpit.
The only override was to cut power to the tail controls, which balances the plane by adjusting the tail, and to do it within about 10 seconds. None of that had been communicated to MAX pilots.
To calm the anger, Boeing sent vice president Mike Sinet to meet pilots at major U.S. airlines. On Nov. 27, Taser and other pilots gathered in a conference room at the union offices in Fort Worth, Texas, ready with questions.
Sinet walked in with a Boeing lobbyist and no presentation materials. With a projector sitting unused, the company men simply sat down empty handed, and Taser sensed spin instead of a technical briefing.
Across the table, the union president quietly hit record on his phone. Sinet began by saying reports that Boeing had added a system without telling anyone were overblown. He added that MCAS was "just a bit of software."
Sinet said a trained pilot and MCAS worked side by side, and that Boeing "didn't want to overload crews with unnecessary information." A pilot shot back that "learning about a system that could kill you seems like the opposite of unnecessary."
Sinet argued that a bad MCAS activation was just one form of a runaway stabilizer, when automatic controls keep moving the tail out of position, and that the checklist was the same whatever the cause.
Taser could not stay quiet. He said thousands of things could go wrong on an airliner, and it took time to diagnose the problem while the controls shook and alarms blared, especially when pilots had never been told to expect it.
Questions people ask
What is MCAS supposed to do?
MCAS automatically pushes an airplane's nose down if data suggest it is climbing too steeply and risking a stall, when the wings lose lift. On the 737 MAX, it did this by moving a large tail surface called the horizontal stabilizer.
What is a runaway stabilizer?
A runaway stabilizer means that tail surface keeps moving on its own, forcing the nose up or down. The standard response is to turn off the electric motor that drives it and then move the tail manually with a hand crank.
What happened in the Lion Air crash?
Lion Air Flight 610 crashed off Indonesia on Oct. 29, 2018, killing all 189 people aboard. Investigators later traced part of the chain to a faulty sensor that fed bad data to MCAS, which repeatedly forced the nose down.


