A Video Store Privacy Law Could Decide What Websites Reveal About You
Broad wording from the Blockbuster era is being tested against online how-to videos and shopping histories.

Original Jurisdiction · ‘There’s Always A Way’: Jaime SantosA law written to keep your trip to the video store private could now control what major websites can reveal about what you watched and bought online.
Appellate lawyer Jaime Santos, who follows business appeals, says the Video Privacy Protection Act was passed to stop rental shops from disclosing customers’ video watching history. It dates to the time when a Supreme Court nominee’s rental records were made public.
The catch, Santos says, is that the law was written very broadly. Read literally, it could apply not just to video stores but to any company that offers videos online and then shares information about a customer’s transactions for goods or services.
Her example is Home Depot and its self-help videos. Her husband watches those videos all the time, she says. The question is whether the law would prevent Home Depot from sharing information showing that he bought a humidifier last year.
Customers bringing these suits say yes. Their argument is simple: look at the words on the page. Companies facing the claims say that was never what the law was meant to do.
That dispute will test how the Supreme Court reads laws. One approach, called textualism, sticks closely to the exact words Congress passed. The other gives more weight to context and purpose, meaning what lawmakers were trying to solve when they wrote those words.
Santos says the importance of the case comes from that broad wording. If courts accept the broad reading, information about ordinary shopping tied to watching online videos could receive new privacy protection.
Questions people ask
What happened with the Supreme Court nominee’s video rentals?
During Robert Bork’s Supreme Court nomination, a list of videos rented by his family was leaked. Lawmakers treated the episode as a warning about personal privacy. Congress then passed the Video Privacy Protection Act.
What does the video privacy law actually forbid?
The law generally bars a video tape service provider from knowingly disclosing information that identifies a person and connects that person to particular videos or similar material. Disclosure is allowed with the customer’s clear consent, a court order, and in some other narrow cases. Much of the current fight is over who counts as such a provider.
Why would a store like Home Depot be treated as a video company?
Plaintiffs argue that a retailer becomes covered when it offers online videos, such as product guides or self-help clips, alongside its store. On that theory, sharing what a viewer bought could count as revealing information tied to video viewing. Companies respond that selling hardware is very different from renting tapes, even if both involve some video.

