KorvaJoin the waitlist
Psychology

A Skeptic Sees Why a Chart Reading Can Feel So Personal

A skeptic's own astrology reading felt personal because it made him feel seen and gave him room to think about himself.

AI image
Bear Brook · A Private Matter, Episode 3

Podcast reporter Jason Moon had come to see astrologer Amy Shapiro to ask about strange encounters she had with the wife of missing Christmas tree farmer Jay Hickey. Shapiro was a former student of Jay's grandmother, Boston astrologer Isabel "Izzy" Hickey, and she does chart readings from her home office.

Shapiro had co-written a book about Izzy with Jay. She keeps Izzy's picture on her desk, set behind crystals. She writes books about astrology and meets with counseling clients at home.

Before Moon's questions, Shapiro read his chart. She told him his sun, a circle with a dot, was in Pisces, which she called the sign of service, and in his third house, which she said emphasized communicating, asking questions, and pursuing information.

Shapiro told him, "You have what I would call a grand trine," adding, "And I'm not saying this just to flatter you."

Moon describes himself as a skeptic at heart. But he told Shapiro he got the appeal, saying something about the reading was fun.

"It makes you introspective in a way that is sort of flattering," he said. "It's like, oh, you get to think about yourself."

Shapiro offered her own summary. "Who doesn't like to be seen?" she asked, adding "that's really at the heart of it."

Moon never says Shapiro described him correctly. He said the reading felt good and let him think about himself.

Questions people ask

What is a birth chart?

A birth chart maps where the sun, moon, and planets appeared to be at the exact time and place of your birth. Astrologers divide the sky into 12 signs and 12 houses, and then interpret those placements as personality traits and life themes. Astronomers do not treat those interpretations as scientific.

What is a grand trine?

It is a pattern formed when three or more planets sit roughly in a triangle across the chart. Astrologers traditionally read it as a sign of natural talent and ease. Astronomers attach no meaning to the alignment.

Who was Isabel Hickey?

Isabel Hickey, called Izzy, was a Boston astrologer and spiritual teacher active in the 1960s and 1970s. She gave readings and lectures and mixed astrology with ideas about Christianity, reincarnation, and karma. Jay Hickey was her grandson, and Shapiro was her student.

More in Psychology