KorvaJoin the waitlist
Startups

Being Called an Entrepreneur Is Not the Same as Acting Like One

Universities focus mainly on teaching knowledge, the authors argue, but becoming a creator takes practice and belonging.

AI image
doi.org · Leveraging Communities of Practice to Cultivate Entrepreneurial Mindset: A Systematic Review and Practical Insights

In a systematic review, researcher Ljerka Sedlan Konig and her coauthors explore how entrepreneurship teaching could better build an entrepreneurial mindset, and name the challenges that get in the way.

After tracing work on learning and identity, they put it this way: "There is a big difference between assuming an identity (he is an entrepreneur) and living out that identity (he behaves entrepreneurially)."

What they mean is that universities are built for knowing. The authors argue that curricula deliver technical knowledge, but offer students too few chances for doing, through practice and engagement, and for being, through forming an identity.

That identity, they write, is socially shaped. It combines relatively stable traits, the expectations attached to a role, and the changeable sense of what it means to belong to a particular group.

Students who identify with a group, the authors argue, absorb its norms and behaviors. Entrepreneurial role models and group standards can help them internalize entrepreneurial values, making the mindset part of who they are rather than a checklist of skills.

That shift is demanding. Joining what the authors call a Community of Practice, a group organized around a shared interest, community, and joint practice, requires adopting its norms, beliefs, and values, which can conflict with a newcomer's existing identity.

The authors write that "Resolving these conflicts is an essential part of forming a new identity and a crucial aspect of developing entrepreneurial behaviour." They also write that "A person who does not identify as a creator, innovator, risk taker, opportunity seeker, initiator, communicator, organizer, collaborator and problem solver is unlikely to succeed in this role."

Such groups, they argue, offer a "playground" where students can practice living that identity, if they are willing to join.

Questions people ask

What exactly is a Community of Practice?

It is a group organized around three things: a shared domain or interest, a community of people who interact, and a shared practice they build together. Examples include doctors sharing treatments, teachers trading lesson ideas, or a student club running real projects.

Does this mean entrepreneurship classes are useless?

No. The authors present formal classes and group practice as complements. Coursework supplies concepts and technical knowledge, while the group supplies mentoring, tacit know-how from experience, feedback, and chances to test ideas.

How does a student move from outsider to insider in such a group?

By taking on small, real tasks alongside more experienced members and moving toward the center as skills grow. Researchers call this legitimate peripheral participation, learning by doing useful work at the edge before leading.

More in Startups