Fast Growth Is Not The Same As A Network Effect
Facebook became more valuable as friends joined, while Airbnb grew because a cheap spare room was worth talking about.

Y Combinator Startup Podcast · #2 - Network Effects with Anu HariharanGrowth is often mistaken for a network effect, says Anu Hariharan, who was a partner at YC Continuity at the time of a 2017 discussion and had studied the subject while at Andreessen Horowitz.
A network effect has a simple test. As more people use a product, it becomes more valuable to the people already using it.
Facebook was her central example. The more friends who joined, the easier it became to connect, trade messages, and see photos and posts in the news feed.
That is different from virality, which is about the speed of growth. Virality often means free growth, or new users arriving without paid marketing because the product is much better than the alternative.
Some virality comes built into use. Early Facebook was an online student directory, and it was not very useful unless classmates were on it, so users invited friends in the same class.
Skype is an example of that kind of growth built into use, not a network effect in this account. A call only worked if the other person was also on Skype, so bringing in friends was part of making it useful.
Airbnb spread differently. At first it let hosts offer spare rooms to travelers, and a guest could book a stay without friends also joining.
People talked about it anyway because the rooms felt less sterile than hotels, were useful when hotels sold out during events, and cost 30 percent to 80 percent less. That is word of mouth, not a network effect.
The way to tell the difference, Hariharan says, is retention. At early Facebook, the share of monthly users who logged in daily kept rising as more people joined, because existing users found the service more useful and came back more often.
Questions people ask
What is the simplest test for a network effect?
Look at whether existing users use the product more as the network grows. For Facebook, that meant a rising share of monthly users logging in each day, because more friends and content made each visit more worthwhile.
Can a company be viral without having a network effect?
Yes. Airbnb is the example. Guests spread it through unpaid recommendations, but booking a room did not require friends to join, so early growth did not make each stay more valuable in the way Facebook did.
Can a company have both at once?
Yes, and early Facebook did. People invited classmates because the directory was useful only if the class was there, which drove fast free growth. That same growth then made the service more valuable to existing users, which is the network effect.
