KorvaJoin the waitlist
History

Dennis Hastert Won His First House Race by Fewer Than 7,000 Votes

The account says his backers used Jill Zwick to brand a Republican rival a religious extremist while he ran as a compassionate conservative, then his campaign sent an unsigned mailing about his Democratic opponent.

AI image
Behind the Bastards · Part One: Dennis Hastert: The Longest-Serving Republican Speaker of the House

In September 1986, Democrat Mary Lou Kearns, the county coroner running for Congress in northern Illinois, was holding a campaign event at a university in northern Illinois when a young man stepped forward from the crowd. He said she had broken up his home.

The accusation reached back to 1978, when Kearns had become engaged to the young man's father. The account says she had not known that the man was still married to his first wife.

The confrontation might have ended as an ugly campaign moment. Instead, the account says, the campaign of Republican Dennis Hastert, then a state legislator and former high school wrestling coach, seized on it with an unsigned mailing that may have helped him win by fewer than 7,000 votes.

Hastert had not started as the nominee. Incumbent Republican John Grotberg had been heavily favored for reelection when he fell into a coma in January 1986 while being treated for cancer, and he resigned that May.

Republican organizer Dallas Ingmanson gathered a small group to plan for the vacancy. Ingmanson decided that Hastert would take over for Grotberg.

Hastert still had to get past other Republicans, above all lawyer Tom Johnson.

To do it, Hastert and his backers arranged for Republican state legislator Jill Zwick to write a letter about Johnson. In Zwick's telling, Johnson was a religious extremist loyal to the Moral Majority, the conservative Christian political group that rated candidates, and she called him a "radical right wing fundamentalist Christian."

The account presents the attack as ironic because Hastert himself had earned a perfect rating from the Moral Majority. He presented himself instead as a compassionate conservative, not a hard line ideologue, and won the nomination.

Against Kearns, Hastert claimed the mantle of President Ronald Reagan at a press event in Washington, declaring that his campaign was really "the last time voters will get to vote for the Reagan agenda." Back home, precinct captains received campaign material that misspelled Reagan's name.

Then, the account says, his campaign sent an unsigned mass mailing to ten thousand voters restating the student's claim that Kearns was a homewrecker.

Hastert won by fewer than 7,000 votes, close enough that the mailer could have mattered. In 1987, he took the seat as the congressman from Illinois' 14th District.

Questions people ask

Who was Mary Lou Kearns?

She was the coroner of Kane County, Illinois, and the Democratic nominee for the 14th District in 1986. In the account, she is running against the favored Republican incumbent before Hastert replaces him as the Republican candidate.

What was the Moral Majority?

It was a conservative Christian political organization founded in 1979 by minister Jerry Falwell. It scored candidates on issues like abortion, school prayer, and gay rights, so a perfect rating signaled strong social conservatism.

Did the unsigned mailer decide the election?

No one can know for certain. Hastert won by fewer than 7,000 votes after the account says his campaign sent the unsigned mailing to 10,000 voters. The account concludes that the margin was close enough that the mailing may have shifted the result.

More in History