For Money Managers, the Middle Is the Most Tenuous Place
HarbourVest chief John Toomey says monthly inflows demand a deal pace that most firms cannot match.

Dry Powder: The Private Equity Podcast · The Market Private Equity Has Yet to Build w/ HarbourVest’s John ToomeyJohn Toomey, who leads investment firm HarbourVest, was pushing back on a prediction about the future of private funds. The chief investment officer of one of the country's largest pension consultants had argued that the whole market would become evergreen, funds that take in new money every month, because those funds are easier to use, even for institutions.
Toomey disagreed. As he put it, "You either need to be scale and you need to deliver lots of things for clients or you need to be niche."
What he meant was a matter of pace. To adequately invest money arriving every month, he said, a firm needs a large volume and steady velocity of investments, and only a few of the largest firms that buy companies directly, and a few multi-manager firms, realistically have it.
He pointed to large, brand-name private equity firms that are still working out how to take in wealthy individuals' money. Such a firm might manage $25 billion to $30 billion, raise an $8 billion to $10 billion fund, and still do only six deals a year.
Those firms ask how six deals a year could absorb that steady flow of new money. He cited them to show monthly inflows don't suit every manager, and he doesn't expect the change to be all or nothing.
For managers in the middle, he said, that makes for what he called a tenuous place. His claim was that a manager needs to offer many things for clients at scale, or to be niche, and he added that there is space for everyone in that system.
Toomey said the pattern extends beyond money management to any industry. As he put it, "But you can't be in the middle."
Questions people ask
What is an evergreen fund?
An evergreen fund stays open and accepts new money on a regular schedule, often monthly or quarterly, rather than raising one closed fund and then closing it. Managers must then keep finding new investments to put that incoming cash to work.
What does a multi-manager firm do?
A multi-manager firm does not usually buy companies itself. It picks outside funds, buys existing fund stakes from other investors, and invests alongside those funds, giving clients broad exposure through one provider.
Why do asset managers want money from wealthy individuals?
They offer diversification beyond public stocks and a chance at higher long-term returns. For firms, they are a large new source of capital as institutions face limits on how much more they can commit.


