KorvaJoin the waitlist
Money

One Ballot for Everyone Could Make Candidates Court Their Rivals' Voters

An open primary plus approval voting would let a voter's second choice count, so attacking a rival could lose you votes.

AI image
The Ezra Klein Show · The Winning Democrat Who Wants to Break Up Political Parties

Rob Sand wants to replace party primaries with one primary for everyone, followed by a general election where voters can pick more than one candidate.

Step one is what he calls the people's primary. Every candidate who qualifies appears on the same ballot, whatever party label they use, and every eligible voter can take part.

The top three to five finishers move on to November. That number matters, Sand argues, because with only two finalists voters can still feel forced to pick the less disliked option through the whole general election.

In that final election, voters would use approval voting. If five names are on the ballot, you can vote for as many as you approve of, not just one, and the candidate approved by the most voters wins. Sand points to Fargo, North Dakota, which he says was the first place to use it.

The goal is to change the math of campaigning. If your rival's supporters can also vote for you, insulting your rival can cost you their second vote, so you have reason to stay respectful, honest, and appealing beyond your base.

Sand prefers approval voting to ranked-choice voting, in which voters rank candidates in order of preference. He says ranking confuses voters and can delay results, while approval voting is instantly clear.

Change would take time, he says. He points to Alaska, which uses a top-four primary. Sand says Sarah Palin ran a harsher first campaign there and a more careful second one after learning that rudeness turned voters away.

The new rules would not end lying or demonizing, Sand says, but they would stop rewarding it.

Questions people ask

How is approval voting different from the system most Americans use now?

In most American elections you pick just one candidate, even if you like several or dislike all the choices. Under approval voting you can vote for each candidate you find acceptable, and each vote counts equally toward that candidate's total.

Where has this kind of system actually been used?

Fargo, North Dakota, adopted approval voting in 2018 and first used it in 2020, and St. Louis adopted it in 2020 and first used it in 2021. Alaska voters approved a top-four primary in 2020, although Alaska pairs it with ranked-choice voting in the general election rather than approval voting.

Would this system help independents and third-party candidates?

It can give them a clearer path to November, because they do not have to win a party primary or petition their way onto the general election ballot. Once there, they can win by collecting broad second-choice support, even if they are few voters' first favorite.

More in Money