KorvaJoin the waitlist
Books

Girgis Says We Honor the Constitution to Coordinate, Not to Guarantee Good Results

Girgis argues deference to an agreed authority lets a vast community cooperate, even when particular answers disappoint.

AI image
Original Jurisdiction · The Disappointed Originalist: Sherif Girgis

When asked why he favors originalism, Sherif Girgis, a law professor, did not point to results.

“I don't think it's that it leads to good outcomes,” Girgis said. “I think the main argument is an argument from the importance of authority.”

By authority, Girgis said he means the shared reference point a vast community needs to coordinate. To promote the common good across such a community, he argued, a legal system must settle disagreements, and that requires deference to a settlement even when it is imperfect.

That is why, in his view, honoring the Constitution means reading it as its adopters understood it should be read. He favors what scholars call original law originalism, interpreting the text according to the interpretive methods accepted at the time, or as lawfully changed since.

Girgis ties the claim to natural law, the idea that reason can identify basic human goods. He lists friendship, knowledge, health, religion, play, and aesthetic experience, and argues that many depend on specialization and the division of labor.

Girgis said that depending on specialization across vast populations requires enormous coordination, which makes the case for authority and, in turn, for honoring it.

He said authority can fade gradually if people stop treating the Constitution as authoritative, but he does not think the United States has reached that point.

He acknowledged limits. If originalism systematically produced horrible outcomes, Girgis said, its case would be defeated and “we would need to go back to the drawing board.”

Authority also has what he called a chicken and egg problem. People must treat a would-be authority as binding before it can actually coordinate them, he said, but once enough people do, the rest owe continued deference unless injustice becomes so great that revolution would better serve the common good.

Questions people ask

What is original law originalism?

It is a version of originalism associated with scholars Will Baude and Stephen Sachs. It says constitutional language should be read using the legal interpretation rules and terms of art that applied when it was adopted, not only ordinary present day meaning.

Does Girgis think Americans could ever stop treating the Constitution as authoritative?

Girgis says yes, in principle. He argues authority depends on people continuing to treat the Constitution as authoritative because it helps coordination. If Americans collectively stopped doing that, or if injustice became so severe that abandoning it served the common good better, the obligation could erode. He does not think the country is there now.

What does Girgis mean by natural law?

He uses it to mean a philosophical tradition, running from Aristotle through Thomas Aquinas to modern thinkers like John Finnis, holding that reason can identify goods central to human flourishing. In this argument, those goods matter because pursuing them requires large scale cooperation, which requires authority.

More in Books