Justice Alito's Judging Is Less Formula, More Judgment
Sherif Girgis says Justice Samuel Alito works between hypotheticals and principles, using precedent and common sense where original meaning runs out.

Original Jurisdiction · The Disappointed Originalist: Sherif GirgisWhen law professor Sherif Girgis, a former clerk to U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, was asked to compare his two clerkship bosses, he started with personality. Former federal appeals judge Thomas Griffith is outgoing, while Alito is reserved until he warms up.
The sharper difference, in his account, was method. Many judges in the conservative legal movement describe an explicit sequence, starting with the text and then moving through other materials with clear rules about which moves are allowed.
Alito, Girgis noted, “was formed by the same movement” as those judges, but thinks more intuitively.
In conferences and drafting, Girgis recalled, “he would start with an instinct” usually driven “by hypotheticals on both sides of the issue.”
In Girgis's description, Alito then moved back and forth between judgments about particular cases and the general principles that might explain them until they fit together. Academics call that process reflective equilibrium.
Girgis stressed that was not working backward from a political result. It was attention to the facts and particulars, a lesson that taught him judging could not work like an algorithm and to value what he called “a lawyerly sense as a guide to legal reasoning.”
That judgment matters because Alito doubts original meaning will settle the cases that reach the top court. Girgis sees him as less confident on that point than some other originalist justices.
So Alito fills gaps with precedent and general standards of reasonableness. Drawing a through line through precedents or history, Girgis argued, is less mechanical and requires common sense about how earlier actors left room to be filled.
Girgis pointed to searches under the Fourth Amendment as an example. Where others might look to the early “common law of trespass to fill” gaps when “how the founders would have applied the norm” is unknown, Girgis said, Alito is more likely to follow precedents and ask what is reasonable.
Questions people ask
What is originalism?
It is the idea that the Constitution should be interpreted according to its original public meaning when it was adopted. Judges disagree about how often that meaning decides hard cases, and what should fill the gaps when it does not.
What is precedent and why does it matter to originalists?
Precedent means earlier court decisions that later courts follow. Even judges committed to original meaning often rely on precedent to keep the law stable and to answer questions the text alone does not resolve.
Who is Thomas Griffith?
Thomas Griffith is a former judge on the federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., where Girgis clerked before joining Alito. Girgis describes him as outgoing, generous and insistent on the best reading of legal materials rather than a preferred outcome.

