KorvaJoin the waitlist
Books

Ordinary Meaning Rarely Settles Hard Constitutional Cases

Common definitions fall short in major cases, says law professor Sherif Girgis.

AI image
Original Jurisdiction · The Disappointed Originalist: Sherif Girgis

Sherif Girgis, a law professor moving from Notre Dame to Harvard in January, was explaining his approach to interpreting the Constitution when he offered an unusual label for himself.

He is, he said, a disappointed originalist. He has been let down because the approach, as he first understood it, did not deliver what he had hoped it would.

Girgis argues that originalism means following the ordinary public meaning of the Constitution's words as understood when they were adopted. He believes that meaning accomplishes far less than its supporters would have hoped.

The problem, he says, is that the hardest cases that reach the Supreme Court turn on sweeping phrases like due process, equal protection, free speech, and executive power. Those phrases, he argues, cannot do almost any of their work by ordinary meaning alone.

You do not decide whether the president can recognize foreign governments, he said, by looking up what executive meant in an old dictionary. Something else has to fill the gap.

What does the work instead, Girgis argues, is something off the page that the words point toward. For the First and Second Amendments, that may be a right that already existed before the Constitution was written.

In other cases, he says, it is older traditions, practices, norms, and expectations. Those materials are only partly captured in early court decisions and legal treatises, which leaves judges with what he called a "mushy soup" of sources rather than a clear textual answer.

His preferred alternative, he said, is original law originalism, an approach developed by Will Baude and Steve Sachs that looks to the interpretive conventions accepted at the time of adoption.

Questions people ask

What is originalism?

Originalism is the view that the Constitution should be interpreted according to its meaning when it was adopted. Supporters say that approach respects the authority of the people who ratified it and helps judges apply fixed law rather than their own preferences.

What does due process mean in the Constitution?

Due process appears in the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments, which bar the government from depriving any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. Courts have read it to cover both fair procedures and some substantive rights, which is why its exact requirements are often disputed.

What is original law originalism, the alternative Girgis favors?

It is an approach associated with legal scholars Will Baude and Stephen Sachs. It says judges should use the interpretive conventions accepted when the Constitution was adopted, including legal terms of art and construction rules that can point beyond the plain sense of the words.

More in Books