KorvaJoin the waitlist
Science

A Model of Power Says New Dictators Purge Their Friends

In one model, fewer supporters means bigger rewards, and bigger rewards buy firmer loyalty.

AI image
CGP Grey · You Would Be a Terrible Leader

The strangest moment after a coup is not the takeover but what comes next. One theory of power from political science predicts the new dictator will push aside some of the fellow revolutionaries who helped him seize power, and keep the underlings of the old dictator.

From the outside, it looks backward. Why abandon friends for the servants of the enemy just removed, people who might still be dangerous?

The theory treats power as simple arithmetic. No ruler rules alone, it argues. He needs a small circle of supporters, generals and officials and money collectors, who raise wealth and enforce orders in exchange for a share of the treasure.

In that model, the rule is to minimize key supporters. A ruler with many supporters has higher bills and more rivalries to balance, which makes it easier for a challenger to peel away enough of them to take over. In that model, rulers with larger inner circles should fall sooner.

The people needed to gain power, in this view, are not the same as the people needed to keep it. Paying a revolutionary hero after his usefulness has ended drains the common pot without helping the ruler stay in charge, just as spending on the public at large does.

The new ruler has also promised larger rewards to the insiders who switched sides, the theory holds. With the same vault to divide, that promise can only be kept by dividing it among fewer people. In the model's logic, fewer mouths means richer rewards, and richer rewards buy firmer loyalty.

Questions people ask

Does this purge logic apply outside dictatorships?

In this model, yes. The same pressure is said to apply to presidents and prime ministers, and to chief executives, deans, mayors, and other heads of small groups. Wherever a leader needs backers to stay in charge, fewer backers would mean more left for each one.

Are the supporters who survive a purge actually more loyal?

Loyalty here is mostly about payment, not affection. Smart supporters are described as watching the balance of power and ready to change sides if the ruler looks like losing. A bigger share makes staying put the better bet.

Why can't a new dictator just pay everyone who helped him?

The vault has not grown. A coup leader is said to have promised greater treasure to those who switched sides, so with the same amount to divide, the treasure must be split among fewer people. Paying old helpers plus new defectors would spread every share thinner.

More in Science