KorvaJoin the waitlist
Health

OCD Drugs Can Help Despite Little Sign Serotonin Is Broken

The pills beat placebo for OCD, but proof of a serotonin problem is weak, and psychiatry often finds drugs that help without proof of the cause.

AI image
Andrew Huberman · The Science & Treatment of Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) | Huberman Lab Essentials

Neuroscientist Andrew Huberman, a professor of neurobiology and ophthalmology at Stanford School of Medicine, had just walked through what helps obsessive compulsive disorder, or OCD, when he stopped for what he called a big surprise.

OCD involves intrusive thoughts that people do not want, plus rituals meant to relieve them. Those rituals give brief relief and then quickly reinforce the intrusive thought.

Despite the benefit from drugs that raise serotonin, he said, there is "very little, if any, evidence that the serotonin system is disrupted in OCD."

It is a split between effect and cause. The drugs, called selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, eased OCD symptoms to a degree and worked better than a dummy pill, yet proof of a broken serotonin system was weak.

The comparison that led up to the remark put cognitive behavioral therapy with exposure first. In a four-week study, symptom scores that ranged from 8 to 28 fell from about 25 to about 11 with that therapy. A placebo did little, the serotonin drugs helped but left symptoms more severe than therapy alone, and combining drugs with therapy added no further benefit.

That therapy gradually faces the trigger and then holds back the ritual, such as washing or checking. The point is learning that anxiety can exist without the ritual, which breaks the loop in which the ritual briefly relieves an intrusive thought and then strengthens it.

A drug can ease symptoms even when the system it acts on did not create the illness. That mismatch is fairly common in psychiatry.

Questions people ask

If serotonin may not be disrupted in OCD, how could a serotonin drug still help?

Generally, a medicine can lessen symptoms without correcting the cause. The underlying cause can remain unknown while the drug still changes symptoms enough to show benefit over a dummy pill.

What is exposure-based therapy for OCD?

A trained therapist gradually exposes the person to what triggers the obsession, then helps the person resist the compulsion, such as washing or checking. The reason it helps is learning to tolerate anxiety rather than relieving it. That breaks the link in which the ritual gives brief relief and then reinforces the intrusive thought.

More in Health