KorvaJoin the waitlist
History

Robert Moses Went After The Man Who Tried To Save Tens Of Thousands Of Bronx Homes

Henry Epstein proposed shifting the Cross Bronx Expressway two blocks to spare a neighborhood, and learned how ruthlessly Moses handled opposition.

AI image
Dwarkesh Podcast · What Robert Caro learned about power after studying it for 50 years

In biographer Robert Caro's account, Bronx politician Henry Epstein confronted New York builder Robert Moses over the Cross Bronx Expressway, saying the chosen route would force out tens of thousands and urging him to shift it two blocks south, where only a couple of hundred would lose their homes.

Caro presents the young Moses as a civil service reformer and idealist who wanted to open Long Island beaches to city residents. That early building, Caro argues, took political genius and will, and at first it served ordinary people.

By the time of the Bronx fight, in Caro's telling, that idealist had hardened into a builder determined to get roads built no matter how many thousands were evicted and no matter what hardships were inflicted.

Moses, Caro says, had come to listen to nobody when he believed a road should be built. People warned him against this expressway before it was built.

To build it, tens of thousands of residents were thrown from their homes without relocation help, in Caro's account. When it opened, Caro calls it the world's longest traffic jam.

Caro says Moses did not debate the two blocks. In his account, he set out to destroy Epstein as an obstacle by making it known that Epstein was having an affair.

Caro offers that episode as his own reading of how Moses operated. In his opinion, Moses learned from early defeats that blocked his plans to look for weaknesses in opponents, whether a mistress or money, and to use whatever he found.

The result, in that reading, was increasing ruthlessness, in which anyone who stood in the way would be removed if Moses could find a way.

The expressway was built on Moses's route. The homes came down, the displaced families had nowhere provided to go, and the traffic stalled almost from the start.

Questions people ask

Who was Robert Moses?

Moses was a New York public official who controlled parks, roads, and large construction programs for decades. He built beaches, parks, bridges, and expressways across the city and Long Island, often by holding several powerful public posts at once.

What went wrong with the Cross Bronx Expressway?

Caro describes it as a highway Moses insisted on building through the Bronx despite objections. In his telling, critics warned against it before construction, and it opened to severe congestion that he calls the world's longest traffic jam.

What happened to the people who were forced out?

In Caro's account, tens of thousands of people were thrown from their homes without relocation help. That meant there was no organized plan to find them new housing.

More in History