You Cannot Pick Your Teenager’s Friends, but You Can Pick Their Norms
Psychologist Angela Duckworth says school culture and neighborhood norms shape teenagers because adolescents closely follow what is normal around them.

Ask Lisa: Untangling Family Life · 295: Situated: How Your Choices Today Shape Your Child's Tomorrow | Angela DuckworthWhen asked what parents can still shape once children become teenagers, psychologist Angela Duckworth, who wrote the book Situated, had a blunt answer about friendship.
“I didn’t get to choose Amanda and Lucy’s specific friends,” she said of her two daughters. “I can’t say you should be friends with her, but not her.”
What parents often can choose, Duckworth argues, is the larger situation where those friendships form. With young children, she said, parents control playdates, meals, and routines, but teenagers insist on making their own choices.
For adolescents, Duckworth pointed to school as an enormously important parent decision, because, in her words, “schools have a culture” and “they attract certain families.” Norms emerge in these schools.
She illustrated it with a boy she had worried would be bullied for having panic attacks. He attended a school where the norm was compassion and care, she said, so classmates looked after him, and he went on to thrive as a first year college student.
Duckworth said she and her husband, Jason, tried to use the same logic with Amanda and Lucy. When the girls were young, the family lived in Narberth, Pennsylvania, a walkable town with a library, a baseball diamond, and children running along sidewalks.
As the girls grew older, the family moved to Center City, Philadelphia, and the daughters attended the public magnet school Masterman. Duckworth described the students there as “really humble, hardworking, ambitious kids who never took anything for granted,” and said the school set the tone around her kids. She said she and her husband chose the school and neighborhood for that reason.
The reason, she argues, is that teenagers are especially sensitive to social cues. They scan their surroundings for what is normal.
Duckworth added a limit: not every family can make these moves, and sometimes the default school and neighborhood are fine. But where parents do have a choice of school or postal code, she said, they are choosing the setting where friendships form.
Questions people ask
Why are teenagers so influenced by peers?
Peer influence rises in adolescence as teenagers spend more time outside the family and care more about status and belonging. Research generally finds friends shape habits around studying, drinking, kindness, and effort, though teenagers also select friends who are already similar to them.
What can parents do if moving or changing schools is not possible?
Duckworth suggests taking the choice seriously rather than accepting the default without thought. Parents can visit schools, ask about discipline and kindness, talk to other families, and consider neighborhoods, worship communities, teams, or activities that reinforce the values they care about.
What kind of school is Masterman?
It is a public magnet school in Philadelphia that admits students through selective criteria. Like many magnet schools, it draws students from across the city who seek a demanding academic program.