KorvaJoin the waitlist
History

Zorro Fought Spaniards to Dodge the Story of Americans Taking California

Clark says that, apparently, Mexican residents cheer California statehood in The Legend of Zorro.

AI image
Stuff You Should Know · Zorro! That guy with the sword!

Chuck Bryant and Josh Clark, hosts of a podcast about Zorro, were discussing why Johnston McCulley set his 1919 pulp serial The Curse of Capistrano decades before his own time. McCulley had built Zorro from legends of bandits from the years when California passed from Spanish and Mexican rule to American rule.

For McCulley, Bryant said, "he gets to avoid just the sort of mess of telling the story of the Anglo takeover of California."

McCulley borrowed the secret double life from The Scarlet Pimpernel, published in 1905, whose hero plays the fop by day and rescues people by night. But he moved the action back to when California was still a Spanish colony.

There Don Diego Vega, a white man of Spanish descent, defends Indigenous residents against Spanish authorities rather than confronting Anglo-Americans. That setup makes Diego look especially noble, Clark observed, a member of the ruling group protecting outsiders from his own side.

He suggested McCulley reshaped history in part because he was writing for an American audience in 1919, sparing readers a messier story about Americans taking land and power in California.

The dodge lasted, in Clark's telling, with later films keeping Zorro fighting everybody except the Americans. As an example he apparently cited the 2005 film The Legend of Zorro, in which Mexican residents cheer as California becomes an American state, an account he called the opposite of what happened.

Bryant agreed that movies often whitewash history to "paint a rosy picture for an audience." And even a Zorro film made in Mexico in 1974 has the hero fighting the local Mexican military, Clark said, though he was tentative about the detail, so Americans still escape the sword.

Questions people ask

Was there a real Zorro?

No, there was no historical Zorro. The character drew on legends of California bandits from the shift from Mexican to American rule, especially Joaquin Murrieta, a Gold Rush-era Sonoran miner turned folk hero, and Solomon Pico, a Californio outlaw who lost land in the American takeover.

What was the Anglo takeover of California?

After the Mexican-American War, the United States took California in 1848, and the Gold Rush brought a flood of newcomers. Many Spanish-speaking landowners lost land in American courts, and an 1850 state law taxed noncitizen miners, pushing some Mexican miners and ranchers toward outlawry.

What is The Scarlet Pimpernel?

It was a 1905 novel and play about Sir Percy Blakeney, an English fop by day who secretly rescues aristocrats from the French Revolution by night. Like Zorro, he wears a mask, wields a sword, hides his identity, and leaves a calling card, in his case a small flower.

More in History