Arguing in Replies May Teach Your Feed to Show You More Posts You Dislike
In a study of 715 X users, likes tracked what people valued, but replies often signaled disagreement that the algorithm may have mistaken for interest.

ndtv.com · Social Media Algorithms May Show Users Content That Goes Against Their Beliefs, Study FindsTo understand why social feeds can feel so irritating, Ziv Epstein, a researcher at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and Michael S. Bernstein, a researcher at Stanford University, followed 715 American adults who actively used X.
With colleagues, and reporting in a peer-reviewed science journal, they compared what people said they valued with what showed up in two places: the Following feed, with posts from accounts users chose, and the For You feed, with algorithmic recommendations.
They proposed that a reply may look like interest, even when it means disagreement. When users answer a post to challenge or criticize it, the researchers argue, the system may take that activity as a sign of relevance and serve up more of the same.
That pattern emerged from close tracking. Participants installed a browser extension that collected posts from both feeds, while an artificial intelligence model classified the values in those posts. Likes and reposts generally matched users stated values, but replies did not.
The mismatch was broad. The For You feed tended to favor order, tradition, rule-following, and security over care, dependability, and environmental protection, and the gap appeared across the political spectrum, though it was more pronounced among Democratic users.
Globally popular posts in the study tended to line up more with Republican values, the team noted, which might clarify why right-leaning users more often saw matching posts without having to argue.
They caution that the finding is not proof. Because they observed natural behavior over 24 hours without experimentally changing the algorithm, they say, they cannot establish that argumentative replies cause the mismatch. Their broader point stands: systems built to maximize engagement may not show people what they genuinely value.
Questions people ask
Should I stop replying to posts I disagree with?
The study cannot prove that, only suggest it. The researchers observed natural behavior without changing the algorithm, so scrolling past rather than replying might reduce such recommendations, but that tactic has not been tested experimentally.
Does this happen on apps other than X?
The study looked only at X, formerly Twitter. Whether the same pattern appears on other apps was not measured here.
Why was the mismatch larger for Democratic users?
The values gap was larger for Democrats in the data. The researchers noted the reply-to-disagree pattern was particularly noticeable among Democratic users, and they suggest the popularity skew may be part of why right-leaning users more often saw matching posts without confrontation.


