X's For You Feed Clashed With Users' Values, Study Finds
The Following feed generally matched what users said they believed, in a study of 715 American adults.

ndtv.com · Social Media Algorithms May Show Users Content That Goes Against Their Beliefs, Study FindsThe team led by MIT researcher Ziv Epstein and Stanford researcher Michael S. Bernstein tracked 715 American adults who use X regularly. Their results, reported in the journal PNAS, show a split between the platform's two main feeds.
Posts in the Following feed, which shows accounts a user chose to follow, generally reflected users' own stated values. Posts in the algorithmic For You feed showed an overall negative relationship, meaning the values on display tended to clash with what users said they believed.
Participants installed a customized browser extension that collected posts from both feeds. An artificial intelligence model classified the values in those posts, and the team compared the results with surveys of participants' personal values.
The For You feed leaned toward order, tradition, rule-following, and security. It gave comparatively less attention to care, dependability, and environmental protection.
The mismatch appeared across the political spectrum but was more pronounced among Democratic users. In activity measured over 24 hours, likes and reposts generally lined up with users' values, while replies did not.
The researchers also found that people often replied to posts they disagreed with in order to challenge them. One possible explanation, which the study does not prove, is that the system can read those argumentative replies as interest and then recommend more of the same frustrating content.
The study was observational and did not test changes to the algorithm, so it cannot show that replies cause the mismatch. The authors say controlled experiments with larger groups are needed to pin down the exact mechanism.
Questions people ask
What is the difference between the Following and For You feeds?
The Following feed shows posts from accounts you chose to follow. The For You feed is chosen by X's recommendation software from across the platform, including accounts you do not follow, based on signals about what may keep you scrolling.
Is a study of 715 people enough to trust?
For a study that required installing tracking software, 715 active users is a substantial sample and allows comparisons across groups. The participants were U.S. adults who use X actively, so the results may not apply to occasional users, teenagers, or users in other countries. The authors themselves call for larger groups and controlled tests.
Can I make my For You feed match my values more closely?
You can spend more time in the Following tab and use X's built-in controls to mute accounts, block accounts, and tell the app you are not interested in a post. Those steps do not guarantee a different For You mix, because the exact causes of the mismatch are still unknown. They do reduce the share of unwanted accounts in what you see.


