Forty Cameras Missed Their Car, and Valeria's Phone Was Miles Away
A missing car on a fixed camera showed where Keith Smith was not, and his daughter's phone showed where they were instead.

Dateline NBC · Deadly IntersectionKeith Smith, a Baltimore husband, told police his wife Jacqueline Smith had been stabbed at a busy intersection after she lowered her car window to give $10 to panhandlers.
Detectives checked that account against the records.
The first problem was time. Video showed Keith leaving the American Legion with Jacqueline, and phone records showed when he called 911. Prosecutor Patrick Seidel said the drive “should have taken about 10 minutes,” but there “was about a 40-minute window” between leaving and the 911 call.
To fill that gap, police got court permission for cell site records, records showing which cell towers a phone had connected to, for the phones of Jacqueline, Keith, and his adult daughter Valeria Smith, who said she was in the car. They sent the records to the FBI for analysis, asked Google for location data, and pulled video from along the claimed route.
Detective Jill Beauregard, a Baltimore homicide detective, reviewed video from about 40 cameras covering the path the pair said they had driven. She never saw their car on any of them.
That absence alone was not proof. Most of those cameras turned in a circle to scan different directions, so a car could theoretically pass while the lens pointed elsewhere, though Beauregard called that highly unlikely.
One camera removed that doubt. A camera at Mulberry Street was fixed in place, aimed at the road Keith said he drove. If he had taken that route, investigators said, that camera should have caught him. It never did.
The phone evidence gave a window of time and a general area, not an exact spot. FBI analysts placed Valeria's mobile device inside Druid Hill Park during a stretch of roughly 10 to 15 minutes that night, nearly four miles from the intersection where Keith and Valeria said the attack happened.
At trial, prosecutor Shondria Hanna, the Baltimore prosecutor who tried the case, tied the two findings together. The absence from the cameras showed where Keith was not, the phone location showed where Valeria was instead, and changing statements, secretly recorded phone calls, and a later flight toward Texas filled out a case built on circumstantial evidence.
Prosecutors also told jurors that Jacqueline planned to divorce Keith and that Keith stood to collect her $800,000 life insurance policy as sole beneficiary. Keith was convicted of first-degree murder.
Questions people ask
How precise is phone location evidence?
Cell site analysis uses records of which towers a phone contacted, and Google location can add GPS and Wi-Fi estimates. In cities the result can narrow a phone to a park or block, but not to an exact bench. In this case, analysts described Valeria's location as a 10 to 15 minute window in Druid Hill Park.
Can cameras really miss a car driving right past them?
In this investigation, detectives said it was possible but highly unlikely that the rotating cameras missed the car. They distinguished those turning cameras from the fixed Mulberry camera, which watched the claimed route continuously and never recorded the car.
What motive did prosecutors claim at trial?
Prosecutors argued money and a divorce. They told the jury that Jacqueline planned to divorce Keith, which could have limited his lifestyle, while her $800,000 life insurance policy named him as sole beneficiary.


