The Young Pilot Followed Boeing's Checklist and Still Could Not Save the Plane
The data showed MCAS firing for 10 seconds, pausing for five, then firing again, while the cockpit transcript showed the crew answered with the correct emergency step.

American Scandal · Encore: Boeing | Impact | 1In a reconstruction, based on historical research, American Airlines pilot Dennis Taser sits down in Chicago at his computer and opens the file showing the recorder's measurements as charts.
The file covers Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302, and it shows when MCAS, software that can automatically force an airliner's nose down, turned on.
It fired for 10 seconds, driving the plane down, then switched off for five seconds while the plane rose, then fired again. Over and over, the cycle repeated.
In the reconstruction, the repeating pattern looks like pilots fighting to keep the aircraft in the air. In the reconstruction, Taser questions whether they grasped what was unfolding, and whether Boeing's emergency instructions could have saved them.
He opens the second document, the transcript from the cockpit voice recorder, which captured what the two pilots said and the alarms they heard.
In the reconstruction, he locates the passage where the captain called for the flaps to be raised, and the instant when MCAS first engaged.
The captain brought extensive experience and 8,000 flight hours. The first officer was younger, and had under 1,000 hours flying in the area.
Then Taser sees what he was looking for. The first officer twice calls to cut the stabilizer trim switches, with the captain agreeing, and the junior pilot shutting down the electric trim.
That step cuts power to the motor that moves the tail panel, and it was exactly what Boeing's safety directive had instructed pilots to do for a faulty MCAS activation.
They had carried out the emergency steps, but it was not enough. In the reconstruction, tears well in his eyes as Taser mutters, "The kid got it right."
In Taser's reading, the junior co-pilot had carried out Boeing's instructions to the letter. Taser concludes the fault lay with MCAS and Boeing, not the crew.
Questions people ask
What is MCAS?
MCAS is software on the 737 MAX that automatically pushes the nose down if it thinks the plane is climbing too steeply. It was meant to make the MAX handle like older 737s, but it could be triggered by a single faulty sensor and was initially not described to many pilots.
What does cutting the stabilizer trim switches do?
Airliners use a movable panel on the tail to balance nose-up and nose-down forces. Cutting the stabilizer trim switches turns off the electric motor that moves it, so pilots must then move it by hand. Boeing's procedure called for that step to stop an unwanted automatic nose-down push.
What happened to the 737 MAX after the Ethiopian crash?
Regulators around the world grounded the 737 MAX after the Ethiopian crash in March 2019, and the United States followed. The plane stayed grounded for about 20 months while Boeing revised the software, added safeguards, and faced investigations and lawsuits.